--- title: Why Your Test Automation Is Failing description: Discover the 3 reasons why your test automation is failing and learn how creating dynamic environments using Environment as a Service solutions can help. image: https://blog.quali.com/hubfs/Test-Automation-Failing.jpg --- [![logo](https://blog.quali.com/hs-fs/hubfs/logo.png?width=120&height=36&name=logo.png "logo")](https://www.quali.com/) - SOLUTIONS - [DEVOPS CLOUD AUTOMATION](https://www.quali.com/solutions/devops-environments/) - [TEST ENVIRONMENTS](https://www.quali.com/solutions/software-test-environments-as-a-service/) - [LAB AS A SERVICE](https://www.quali.com/solutions/network-and-security-dev-test-lab-as-a-service/) - [SALES DEMO/VIRTUAL POC](https://www.quali.com/solutions/sales-demos-virtual-poc-environments/) - [CYBER RANGE ENVIRONMENTS](https://www.quali.com/solutions/cyber-range-environments/) - [VIRTUAL TRAINING LABS](https://www.quali.com/solutions/virtual-training-labs/) - [PRODUCTS](https://www.quali.com/cloudshell-platform/) - [CloudShell Pro](https://www.quali.com/cloudshell-pro/) - [Product](https://www.quali.com/cloudshell-pro/) - [Community](https://www.quali.com/community/) - [University](https://www.quali.com/university/) - [Support](https://support.quali.com/) - [CloudShell Colony \[NEW\]](https://www.quali.com/cloudshell-colony/) - [Product](https://www.quali.com/cloudshell-colony/) - [Request Free Trial](https://app.cloudshellcolony.com/sign_up?utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Ffreedcamp.com%2FJacobs_Work_Projects_gNM%2FQuali_7GO%2Ftodos%2F25066065%2F&__hstc=208618317.2af89ba750e0bbc1c35b7c40ea6ff838.1567174142272.1567174142272.1567174142272.1&__hssc=208618317.1.1567174142272&__hsfp=1037199243) - [Login](https://app.cloudshellcolony.com/login?__hstc=208618317.2af89ba750e0bbc1c35b7c40ea6ff838.1567174142272.1567174142272.1567174142272.1&__hssc=208618317.1.1567174142272&__hsfp=1037199243) - [CUSTOMERS](https://www.quali.com/customers/) - [RESOURCES](https://www.quali.com/resource-center/) - [Blog](https://blog.quali.com/blog/) - Financial Services - [Financial Services Application Continuous Delivery](https://www.quali.com/financial-services-application-continuous-delivery/) - [Infrastructure Environments for Banks and Financial Services](https://www.quali.com/environment-as-service-for-banks-finserv/) - [FAQ](https://www.quali.com/faq/) - [Resource Library](https://www.quali.com/resource-center/) - [COMPANY](https://www.quali.com/about-us/) - [About Us](https://www.quali.com/about-us/) - [Leadership](https://www.quali.com/about-us/#management) - [News and Events](https://www.quali.com/about-us/news-events/) - [Partners](https://www.quali.com/partners/) - [Locations](https://www.quali.com/about-us/#locations) - [Careers](https://www.quali.com/about-us/careers/) - [Awards](https://www.quali.com/awards/) - [CONTACT US](https://info.quali.com/contact-us) ### Blog Stay up to date with blogs written by experts in the fields of cloud automation, infrastructure orchestration, and devops. ### Why Your Test Automation Is Failing # Why Your Test Automation Is Failing ![header-picture](https://blog.quali.com/hubfs/Test-Automation-Failing.jpg "header-picture") **Author:** Maya Ber Lerner **Published:** June 05, 2019 **Share it:** - - - - [mailto:?&subject=https://blog.quali.com/blog/why-your-test-automation-is-failing&body=https://blog.quali.com/blog/why-your-test-automation-is-failing](mailto:?&subject=https://blog.quali.com/blog/why-your-test-automation-is-failing&body=https://blog.quali.com/blog/why-your-test-automation-is-failing) ![header-picture](https://blog.quali.com/hubfs/Test-Automation-Failing.jpg "header-picture") This article originally appeared on [DevOps.com](https://devops.com/why-your-test-automation-is-failing/) One of the most common issues is that the test part of test automation is rather straightforward to automate, especially with today’s abundance of great automation tools. But jumping straight into automated testing leaves you with a big heap of automation scripts, and often not the best ROI. Understanding why requires looking into the automation process. When an engineer builds an automated test, they do it in a test environment that they (or someone in the organization) set up. Usually, this is the same way manual testers get access to test environments. Before the engineers start automating, they have a working copy of the product they are [testing](https://devops.com/how-ai-is-transforming-testing-today/), with relevant data on it. They have a good idea of the test they want to write. Everything looks promising. They write the test and give it a few runs. Everything is looking nice and stable. Now, to provide the ROI we were hoping for, the test must run a million times. Or, at least, a few thousand times, right? To reap the benefits of automation, it needs to happen frequently enough. However, the bottleneck is often discovered after creating a bunch of tests. Because the tests must run on a similar test environment to the one used to create them, with the new versions of the product or with any introduced changes that are being tested, you need access to hundreds of environments. This requirement makes it difficult to test effectively. Below are three test environment approaches that inhibit test automation. ### Manually Setting Up an Environment Each Time to Run Automated Tests For tests that don’t need to run as frequently, such as security testing and performance testing, it’s common to set up an environment for automated tests every time the test needs to be executed. As a result, testers must wait for the environment to be ready, perhaps do some additional configurations and then run a suite of tests. And, if they’re trying to optimize utilization, the environment is left to run overnight or weekend. The problem with this approach is it takes the “auto” out of automated testing. When automation depends on a manual step, the test is only as efficient as this manual step. If the manual step isn’t very efficient, automation may not be helping at all. I’ve seen companies take so long to get an environment to work that running automated tests on it didn’t make any difference from a time perspective. ### Setting Up a Static Environment That Automation Always Runs On When setting up an environment takes a long time, it’s natural to assume it’s worth leaving an environment running so test automation can run on it. The preparations were made, the infrastructure is all in place, the product is configured and the data is ready, so let the automation party begin. While complex, static test environments may seem ideal, but the party doesn’t last long. First, since it usually takes some time to put the environment together (same as the previous case), it often becomes high-maintenance. It can be scary to make changes that could ruin things, and you can end up needing someone to manage change full-time. Much like chocolate cake in the office kitchen, an environment that mimics production with good data on it tends to attract everyone. Soon, these nice environments become shared assets and tests start conflicting for the same resources. The natural next step is to set up another static environment. This loop usually ends with an angry manager saying something about cutting CAPEX. ### Automating the Environment and Cutting Ourselves Some Slack With the rise of infrastructure as code ([IaC](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infrastructure_as_code)) and immutable infrastructure, there are more ways to spin up a test environment. Resourceful test teams will try to automate the environment creation or use built-in test tool or CI system capabilities to run tests on a public cloud instance or a container, if the product they test allows that. This is cheap and useful—and could work for some simple tests. The challenge usually starts with everything this approach doesn’t cover. It can be difficult to use IaC to spin up a test environment and handle all aspects of it—from security and isolation to dependencies, data, third-party integration and more. This is where this approach is often blocked and sends us back to the previous two approaches for a big part of the testing load—which again makes test automation investment less fruitful. ### The Right Way to Set Up Test Environments: Test Automation on Dynamic Environments The test automation world needs a game changer. You can make your car faster, but if the road is full of potholes, you won’t be able to get that fast or far. Test automation is similarly limited by the pace of environment creation, with its infrastructure, application, data and all. This challenge becomes critical when adopting DevOps and testing stops being a stage in the pipeline, instead becoming an overall pipeline service. QA is no longer about being the gate between development to operations. It’s about overseeing the quality of the product during its entire life cycle. This means automated tests should always be able to run, and the environment they run on must be dynamic. The solution to this challenge is environments as a service (EaaS). EaaS is all about packaging the environment, including the application, infrastructure and data, as an entity that can be provided as a service to a business process. Once defined, it can be provided on-demand for manual or automated users. Since it’s a well-defined entity, it also can be decommissioned when the process finishes using it. Playing an important role in making infrastructure horizontal, EaaS is also the key for paving the road for brilliant test automation. If you think you should get more from your test automation initiative, it may be a good time to make EaaS part of your automation strategy. - Posted by Maya Ber Lerner on June 05, 2019 - About Author: Maya is Chief Technology Officer and Chief Evangelist at Quali. Originally a biomedical engineer, she somehow got into software and automation, and immediately felt at home. When not traveling she is the IT person at home, and the only one allowed to change router configurations. Outside of work, she likes drawing, carving, and reading. By Sean Harris - 05 June, 2019 #### 4 Major Business Problems Solved by Infrastructure Automation [![read more](https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/685080/IMG-TurboSodium/Sodium%20v2/blog/arrow-recent-blog-post.png "read more")](https://blog.quali.com/blog/4-major-business-problems-solved-by-infrastructure-automation) By Pascal Joly - 05 June, 2019 #### Infrastructure Automation at Scale: Blueprinting vs. Terraform [![read more](https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/685080/IMG-TurboSodium/Sodium%20v2/blog/arrow-recent-blog-post.png "read more")](https://blog.quali.com/blog/environment-as-a-service-blueprinting-vs.-terraform) By Sean Harris - 05 June, 2019 #### Why Infrastructure Automation Is Critical for Cyber Security [![read more](https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/685080/IMG-TurboSodium/Sodium%20v2/blog/arrow-recent-blog-post.png "read more")](https://blog.quali.com/blog/why-infrastructure-automation-is-critical-for-cyber-security) ### Recent Posts ### Posts by Topic - [DevOps (69)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/devops) - [Sales Demo (24)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/sales-demo) - [Dev/Test (21)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/dev-test) - [Automation (12)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/automation) - [infrastructure automation (12)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/infrastructure-automation) - [Environment as a Service (11)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/environment-as-a-service) - [colony (9)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/colony) - [ci/cd pipeline (6)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/ci-cd-pipeline) - [demo PoC (6)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/demo-poc) - [Qualifyi (5)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/qualifyi) - [Continuous Integration/Delivery (4)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/continuous-integration-delivery) - [Lab as a Service (4)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/lab-as-a-service) - [cloudshell pro (4)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/cloudshell-pro) - [Cloud and Virtualization (3)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/cloud-and-virtualization) - [Cyber Range (3)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/cyber-range) - ["infrastructure as code" (2)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/infrastructure-as-code) - [Sales Clouds (2)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/sales-clouds) - [Sales Demo/PoC (2)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/sales-demo-poc) - [Test & Test Lab Automation (2)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/test-test-lab-automation) - [application release (2)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/application-release) - ["trial demo" (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/trial-demo) - [DevOps/Agile IT (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/devopsagile-it) - [DevSecOps (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/devsecops) - [Events (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/events) - [JFrog (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/jfrog) - [Product Release (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/product-release) - [SDN & NFV (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/sdn-nfv) - [SDN & NFV & Networking (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/sdn-nfv-networking) - [Security (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/security) - [TechBlog (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/techblog) - [artifactory (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/artifactory) - [continuous testing (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/continuous-testing) - [continuous validation (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/continuous-validation) - [parallel delivery (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/parallel-delivery) - [repository (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/repository) - [salesforce (1)](https://blog.quali.com/blog/topic/salesforce) View More   #### 4 Major Business Problems Solved by Infrastructure Automation Every company and organization that develops software and applications needs environments. As they race toward innovating new products and... [Read More](https://blog.quali.com/blog/4-major-business-problems-solved-by-infrastructure-automation)   #### Infrastructure Automation at Scale: Blueprinting vs. Terraform \[This blog was originally published in November of 2019 and updated with new content in May of 2021.\] Whether you are a software architect,... [Read More](https://blog.quali.com/blog/environment-as-a-service-blueprinting-vs.-terraform)   #### Why Infrastructure Automation Is Critical for Cyber Security Revelations about the recent SolarWinds hack have highlighted the evolving sophistication and growing effectiveness of cyber attacks,... [Read More](https://blog.quali.com/blog/why-infrastructure-automation-is-critical-for-cyber-security) ##### **Join 11,000+** CIOs, CTOs, ITOps, and DevOps practitioners on our newsletter and blog list Emails once or twice a week on cloud automation, infrastructure orchestration, and DevOps ![](https://blog.quali.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Blue%20Arrow%201.png?width=69&name=Blue%20Arrow%201.png) ![footer-curve](https://blog.quali.com/hubfs/footer-curve.png "footer-curve") ### About Quali Quali provides the leading platform for Infrastructure Automation at Scale. Global 2000 enterprises and innovators everywhere rely on Quali’s award-winning CloudShell platform to create self-service, on-demand automation solutions that increase engineering productivity, cut cloud costs, and optimize infrastructure utilization. ### Media Contacts **PR**     pr AT quali.com ![](https://www.quali.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/logo-quali.png) Quali is the industry leader in delivering cloud-agnostic Environment as a Service (EaaS) solutions for development and testing, sales demo/POC, training, and cyber range teams. Global 500 OEMs, ISVs, financial services, retailers, and innovators everywhere rely on Quali’s award-winning CloudShell platform to create self-service, on-demand environments that cut cloud costs, optimize infrastructure utilization, and increase productivity. SOLUTIONS [DevOps Cloud Automation](https://blog.quali.com/solutions/devops-environments/) [Test Environments](https://blog.quali.com/solutions/software-test-environments-as-a-service/) [Lab as a Service](https://blog.quali.com/solutions/network-and-security-dev-test-lab-as-a-service/) [Sales Demos/Virtual PoCs](https://blog.quali.com/solutions/sales-demos-virtual-poc-environments/) [Cyber Range Environments](https://blog.quali.com/solutions/cyber-range-environments/) [Virtual Training Labs](https://blog.quali.com/solutions/virtual-training-labs/) INDUSTRY SPOTLIGHT [Financial Services Application Continuous Delivery](https://blog.quali.com/solutions/financial-services-application-continuous-delivery/) [Lab as a Service for Banks](https://blog.quali.com/solutions/environment-as-service-for-banks-finserv/) PRODUCTS [CloudShell Pro](https://blog.quali.com/cloudshell-pro/) [- Community](https://blog.quali.com/community/) [- University](https://blog.quali.com/university/) [- Support](https://blog.quali.com/community/support/) [- Integrations](https://community.quali.com/integrations) [CloudShell Colony](https://blog.quali.com/cloudshell-colony/) [- Product](https://community.quali.com/integrations) [- Integrations](https://community.quali.com/integrations) [- Login](https://community.quali.com/integrations) [PRICING](https://info.quali.com/pricing) RESOURCES [Resource Center](https://blog.quali.com/resource-center/) [Blog](https://blog.quali.com/blog/) [FAQ](https://blog.quali.com/faq/) COMPANY [About Us](https://blog.quali.com/about-us/) [Why Quali](https://blog.quali.com/why-quali/) [Customers](https://blog.quali.com/customers/) [Leadership](https://blog.quali.com/about-us/#leadership) [Newsroom](https://blog.quali.com/about-us/newsroom/) [Locations](https://blog.quali.com/about-us/#locations) [Careers](https://blog.quali.com/about-us/careers/) [Awards](https://blog.quali.com/about-us/#awards) [PARTNERS](https://blog.quali.com/partners/) LEGAL [Legal](https://blog.quali.com/legal/) [Privacy Policy](https://blog.quali.com/qualiprivacypolicy/) [Cookie Notice](https://blog.quali.com/cookie-notice) INFO [Contact Us](https://info.quali.com/contact-us) **+1 877 QUALI 10** **[info@quali.com](mailto:info@quali.com)** © Qualisystems LTD 2020 ![](https://www.bizographics.com/collect/?pid=7400&fmt=gif)